Newsgroups: sci.math
From: Robert Israel <isr...@math.MyUniversitysInitials.ca>
Date: Wed, 09 Jul 2008 20:47:04 -0500
Local: Thurs, Jul 10 2008 6:47 am
Subject: Re: A set of approximations the central binomial coefficient
> > In article <20080706103816.687...@newsreader.com>, > > >> C(2n, n) ~= 4^n / sqrt( Rm(n) ) > > >> Rm being a rational function of max. degree m+1 (m>0): > > >> Rm(n) = (pi n^(m+1) + sum(i=0,m) Pi n^i) / (n^m + sum(i=0,m-1) Qi > > >> and where the 2m+1 coefficients are defined by simply requiring exact > > >Hello, Knud! > > >Yes, your form of approximation is nice. > > >FWIW, here are simple upper and lower bounds for C(2n, n). > > >Upper bound: 4^n / sqrt(pi(n + 1/4)) (Ub) > > >Lower bound: Ub * (1 - 1/(8(n + 1/4))^2) (Lb) > > >Your approximations are precise for small n, while the relative errors > > Using Stirling's assymptotic series, we get that the central binomial > > 4^n 1 1 5 21 > > which, using the first 3 terms, gives > > n C(2n,n) approximation > > Multiply by sqrt(1 + 1/(4n)) / sqrt(1 + 1/(4n)) to get > > 4^n 1 1 3 > > Substituting m = n+1/4, we get > > 4^m 1 21 > > Using one and two terms in the series, we get your approximations. > > The interesting part is that out to the 1/m^50 term, the series is > That can't be literally true. For example, C(2m-1/2,m-1/4) 4^(-m) sqrt(m) ln(Q) = ln(Gamma(2m+1/2)) - 2 ln(Gamma(m+3/4)) - 2 m ln(2) + ln(m)/2 (d/dm) ln(Q) = 2 Psi(2m+1/2) - 2 Psi(m+3/4) - 2 ln(2) + 1/(2m) Now it looks to me like Psi(m+t) - Psi(m+1-t) has only odd powers of m in its where Psi(k,x) is the k'th derivative of Psi(x). Now asymptotically You must Sign in before you can post messages.
To post a message you must first join this group.
Please update your nickname on the subscription settings page before posting.
You do not have the permission required to post.
| ||||||||||||||